Ella Langley and Riley Green are quickly becoming one of country music’s favorite duos. Their hit single, You Look Like You Love Me, is still climbing the charts, but during a recent concert, they gave fans a little something extra—a brand-new duet that no one saw coming.

In the middle of their set, Green surprised the crowd by introducing a brand-new song titled Don’t Mind If I Do, which he wrote himself. It was the very first time the two had ever performed it live.

“We’ve got a big song together. Some of y’all may have heard that one,” Green said with a smile, nodding to their current hit. “But we also have another song that we haven’t played in front of anybody before. We’re thinking about playing it in front of y’all tonight, if y’all don’t mind.”

Then, with a grin, he added, “So wish us luck here—and if we mess it up, don’t post it,” earning a laugh from the crowd.

Much like their first duet, Don’t Mind If I Do leans into a traditional country sound, but this one takes a more emotional turn. While You Look Like You Love Me is playful and flirtatious, Don’t Mind If I Do explores the raw feelings of heartache and lingering love after a breakup.

The song opens with Green’s character, lost in thought and nursing a drink, wishing he could just show up at his ex’s doorstep and tell her how he feels. As the story unfolds and Langley’s voice joins in, it becomes clear that the feelings are mutual—leaving just enough hope that the relationship might not be over after all.

The chemistry between the two artists is undeniable, both in the studio and on stage. Their latest music video for You Look Like You Love Me, which features a Wild West vibe and a cameo from Jamey Johnson, proves just that.

To top it all off, Green just announced his upcoming album—Don’t Mind If I Do—set to drop on October 18, which also happens to be his birthday. Fans can likely expect even more heartfelt country storytelling on the new project.