THE UNFINISHED SONG: The Beatles’ Last Note Between Memory and Farewell
In the autumn of 1979, inside his New York apartment, John Lennon sat down at his piano and pressed the record button on a humble cassette deck. What emerged was fragile, almost hesitant — a skeletal sketch of a ballad he titled “Now and Then.” His voice, tinged with both weariness and warmth, carried lines that hinted at longing and reconciliation. Yet the song was left unfinished, cut short, a fragment destined to linger in silence for decades.
After Lennon’s death in 1980, the cassette became more than just a tape; it became an artifact. For years, it remained tucked away, its hiss and imperfections a reminder of how much had been left unsaid. When Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr revisited it in the 1990s alongside George Harrison, the technology of the time failed them. The piano bleed and background hum rendered the track nearly impossible to complete. So the song returned to its box, suspended in history — Lennon’s voice, forever waiting.
Fast forward to 2025. Advances in sound restoration finally allowed Paul and Ringo to do what once seemed impossible: to bring clarity to Lennon’s fragile vocal and shape the unfinished demo into a complete recording. With George’s earlier guitar contributions carefully woven in, the track was reborn, not as a perfect Beatles single, but as a final conversation between friends across the distance of time.
When it was released, reactions split. For some, it was catharsis — the last missing piece, a gift to generations who had lived in the echo of Let It Be and The Long and Winding Road. Hearing Lennon’s voice rise once more alongside Paul and Ringo felt like the closing of a circle, a gentle curtain call for a story that had always seemed too big to end.
For others, though, it reopened old wounds. The rawness of Lennon’s voice, stripped of the fullness he might have given it in life, carried a ghostly quality that felt less like celebration and more like haunting. Critics asked if the past should have been left untouched, if the beauty of the unfinished song was in its very incompleteness.
Paul, reflecting on the decision, admitted that it wasn’t easy. “Every time I heard John’s voice on that tape, it felt like he was in the room again. That’s not something you walk away from lightly. We did it because we wanted to honor him — and because we still miss him.” Ringo echoed the sentiment: “It was emotional. Hard, too. But we wanted to give people what John started. To let his song live.”
In the end, “Now and Then” exists as both tribute and question. It is a song that carries the weight of friendship, loss, and the impossible desire to turn back time. It is the sound of Lennon reaching across the years, and his brothers answering one final time.
Was it closure, or was it the reopening of an old wound? Perhaps it was both. For those who press play, what they hear is not just music, but history breathing again — a reminder that some songs never truly end.
